honestly I enjoyed it I actually like the fact that it makes you have to think to find an underlying meaning. As for the silenced silencing the silent I think It could mean something different to the author but perhaps they meant something along the lines of one already being silent but thinking of speaking up until they see another whom is silent for the same or a similiar reasons

. As far as the spelling goes the author did say it was a rough draft

so yes that should perhaps be fixed up for the final copy

. It may be a bit confusing to the reader BUT if you understand it superior thats all that really counts